”More
Dynamic Range Day - Loudness War Protest

Production Advice

unlock the potential of your music

How to use compression to add punch, warmth and power to your mix

Image by Jason Tavares - click for more info

 

Using compression in your mixes is essential – and you need to use it right.

OK, maybe not if you play classical harp or Polynesian nose-flute – but in most genres, using compression to control the dynamic range of instruments in the mix is fundamental.

The problem is, learning to use compression isn’t easy. And it’s not helped by the fact that most explanations start out saying something like “a compressor reduces the dynamic range of it’s input by attenuating signals that exceed a pre-defined threshold”.

Or something.

Personally I don’t find this kind of description very intuitive, so this post will try and keep things straightforward. So before we go to much further:

What is compression, and why use it ?

Here is the explanation I was given as a trainee:

Compression is used to make things louder

Meaning, you can use it to lift levels in the mix without overwhelming everything else. Most sounds are very “peaky” to begin with, with lots of contrast between the loudest and the softest notes.

Compressors automatically turn down the loudest parts of a sound, and as a result make the average level more consistent. So, you can turn the overall level up in the mix without distorting or “sticking out”.

There can be all kinds of positive side-effects of this process, like making things sound fuller, richer, more controlled or punchier, but at the end of the day it’s all about loudness. Not excessive loudness, but something musically beneficial.

Using a compressor – an introduction

Here’s a fantastic video introduction to compression by Joe Gilder from the excellent Home Studio Corner blog. Check it out, and then I’ll expand on some of the points he makes, and offer some suggestions for achieving specific effects using compression.

 

Exploring compressor controls

Joe’s video is great, but there’s no substitute for trying this stuff yourself. Try overdoing everything to begin with, so you get a feeling of what the different parameters do. Toggle bypass on and off to clearly hear the effect, but make sure you adjust the make-up gain so the levels before and after are similar for a fair comparison. 

Here are some pointers to get you started.

Ratio & Threshold

  • High ratios (4:1) with high thresholds give a “hard hitting” sound for punch and thump. Watch out for pumping and sucking, or even distortion
  • Lower ratios (2:1) with lower thresholds give softer “warming” or “thickening” effects
  • A low threshold with a high ratio will give lots of hard compression and probably sound very squashed and lifeless

Attack & Release Time

  • As a rule, avoid short (low) attack and release times, as Joe says. 
  • Fast attack times can be useful, for softening very spiky sounds (eg. slapped bass) but can remove life and impact if overdone, especially with a high ratio
  • Long attack times with high ratio and threshold give the classic “thump-suck-relax” pumping sound – for example, listen to “One More Time” by Daft Punk
  • Automatic or “intelligent” settings reduce “unnatural” effects like this, but increase the risk of using too much compression without realising it.

 

The Golden Rule

If the gain reduction meter doesn’t return to zero several times a bar, you’re almost certainly using too much compression

- because this means that the signal is being compressed all the time, and will probably sound squashed or flattened as a result. Try a higher threshold, and then higher ratio if it’s not doing enough.

Use your ears

Don’t be tempted to compress everything, or to over-compress. The TT Dynamic Range Meter plugin can be a valuable aid to judging how much compression to use, but always listen to the sound before and after compression, and ask yourself these questions:

  • Which do I prefer ?
  • Have I achieved what I wanted ? (ie. made it punchier, fuller, with more impact & excitement)
  • Does the compressed version still sound lively and exciting, or is it too squashed ?
  • Does it sound closer to similar tracks I’m trying to emulate ?
  • Can I hear more of the quiet details in the mix, or is it getting “mushy” and confused ?
  • Does it still sound natural ?

Hopefully these pointers will get you started on the way to using compression effectively in your mixing – in future posts I’ll look at different types of compressor and more advanced compression techniques. 

What are your favourite compression techniques ? Or, do you prefer not to use compression at all ?

 

3 Responses

  1. James Pew says:

    Great post Ian.

    I find that when working with “peaky” acoustic instruments (upright bass, acoustic guitar, drums, fiddle, etc) using a low ratio like 2:1 with a higher threshold (15 or more db) can help to smooth the peaks while allowing the instrument to still sound natural.

    But of course this all depends on how the instrument is recorded and how obnoxious the peaks are.

    I used this compression approach to practically every instrument in a production called “Reverie” of New Folk artist Andrea Gauster…you can hear it at http://brokenwindowrecords.com/artists/andrea-gauster/

  2. 2:1 ratio seems like a nice place to rest most compression additions. seems like every time i turned around, my professors were harping on compression ratios…or some other ‘Berklee method”…I like the 2009 method, there are few rules to production, i think. templates are great, genre specific guidelines are great, doing what the hell you want to achieve a nice mix…now thats what im talking about. ;) i would argue too many tools have taken away from music by way of deleting the raw.

  3. Taylor says:

    Great write-up, Ian. Interesting, clear, logical and useful. Thanks. I look forward to reading more.

Leave a Reply

Would you like experienced, affordable, professional feedback for your recordings?

As an experienced mastering engineer and producer, I can give you the insight and analysis you need, exactly when you need it. With Production Advice, you are in charge. Click here to get expert, impartial opinions to make the best choices for your recording and mix early in the production process.

Praise for Production Advice

"I knew what Ian was going to say before he'd even finished saying it - and I couldn't believe it hadn't occurred to me before. That's what his advice gave me: perspective. Exactly when I need it."
- Richard Durrant from Longman Records
Read more of what people are saying and judge for yourself

Read a sample Post

Click to read an example post from Production Advice - different every time

Receive updates

By RSS Feed

(Click here for more info)

 

Or by email:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Send me your track

Send me your track
(But read this first !)
TRY IT OUT
SOLUTIONS
INDEX
RESOURCES
BOOKSHOP
FAQ
 

Listen to Ian on BBC Radio 4

Please install Flash plugin

Ian Shepherd from Production Advice discusses the Loudness Wars
 

Connect with Ian on Twitter

Mastering Pro Tools

Tag Cloud